The underbelly of news media

September 29, 2024

Life changes drastically when a journalist goes from chasing stories to becoming the story

The underbelly of news media


A

lfonso Cuarón’s Disclaimer, a 2024 Apple TV+ psychological thriller based on Renée Knight’s novel, is an immersive and meticulously crafted narrative that shines a light on the darker corners of journalism, guilt and human frailty. The mini-series will be released on October 11.

Cate Blanchett commands the screen as Catherine Ravenscroft, a seasoned journalist whose career has been built on revealing uncomfortable truths. The series is an intelligent, layered puzzle that straddles the boundary between professional integrity and personal ruin.

What unfolds is not just a race against time to uncover the mystery, but also a descent into the dark, labyrinthine corridors of guilt and memory. As the gray fog of Catherine’s professional detachment gives way to the deepening darkness of personal reckoning, Disclaimer invites the viewers to question how far one can go in exposing the truth before it consumes one.

Dark tones and shadowy cinematography set the stage from the very first scene for a story steeped in tension, mystery and moral ambiguity. Disclaimer deliberately plays with light and darkness, both visually and metaphorically, using a somber, bruise-like palette to echo Catherine’s internal descent. The smoky grays and inky blacks on screen seem to creep into her life as her past slowly unravels, painting a portrait of a woman whose unblemished exterior masks a haunted soul.

At the heart of the series is the issue of ethics and truth-telling: how a journalist like Catherine, who has made a name for herself by exposing others’ wrongdoings, must confront her own moral quandary when the story suddenly focuses on her.

Blanchett gives a subtle performance, portraying a character who has spent her life scrutinising others but is now the focus of scrutiny. Her misdeeds, long hidden beneath layers of professional achievement and public respect, are exposed when a novel exposing her worst transgressions is published.

The chilling premise of Disclaimer draws viewers into Catherine’s frantic quest to unmask the anonymous author. It is not just the exposure of her past at stake. Her relationships with her husband Robert, portrayed by actor Sacha Baron Cohen, and son Nicholas, played by Kodi Smit-McPhee, teeter on the brink of collapse as her secrets emerge.

The tension between Catherine and Robert is palpable, their conversations laden with the weight of unspoken betrayals and simmering guilt. Nicholas, their aimless, drug-addled son, drifts through the series like a ghost, emphasising the damage hidden truths have inflicted on their family.

The cinematography acts like a character in the series. The bluish-gray hues evoke Catherine’s public persona; cold, polished and unflinching. Beneath this veneer, a storm brews. Dark, oppressive tones engulf the screen as her life spirals out of control, illustrating the suffocating nature of the lies she has long tried to suppress. The series doesn’t shy away from the psychological cost of her profession. Instead, it delves into the heavy burden of carrying the secrets of others and denying her own.

This theme is powerfully personified in Kevin Kline’s Stephen Brigstocke, a retired teacher whose son Jonathan, played by Louis Partridge, allegedly had an affair with Catherine before his death. Stephen’s seething grudge against Catherine adds layers to the story’s ethical debate.

What makes Disclaimer particularly compelling is how it tackles broad societal issues tied to journalism. Cuarón’s direction, aided by a stellar ensemble cast, illustrates the ethical dilemmas faced by journalists who must balance the public’s right to know against the damage that truth can inflict. Catherine, whose work has revealed injustices and transgressions, finds herself trapped in the machinery she once wielded against others. As her life begins to mirror the stories she once exposed, the series raises important questions. Who watches the watchers? At what point does the pursuit of truth become another form of exploitation?

The duality of the nature of her work forces Catherine to ponder over her character as a hero and as a villain forged by the societal demand and the invasive nature of media that surpasses all personal boundaries. It mirrors society’s complicated relationship with the media. While people demand transparency and justice, they often forget that those who deliver the news are human and can be deeply affected by their work. The media’s role in shaping public opinion cannot be overstated.

Disclaimer shines a light on the dangers of unmonitored power in journalism. It suggests that those in control of narratives must also be held accountable for the stories they choose to tell and the people they may harm in the process. The series explores how the pressures of constantly delivering stories can push journalists to the breaking point.

The mini-series also points out the news industry’s frequent failure to adequately address mental health issues and provide support for those expected to investigate the most traumatic aspects of society. In an industry that prioritises objectivity and detachment, journalists are often left alone to cope with the emotional impact of their work.


The writer has a degree in psychology with a minor in mass communication. She can be reached at ukmaryam2@gmail.com

The underbelly of news media