that elusive partnership that we traditionally moan about – between the bureaucrat and the political representative. The benefit of appointing competent and efficient officials for these critical offices in KP seems to be trickling down to district levels. This, despite a spanner called Fazalur Rehman.
Merit and commitment can be measured by the fact that some district officials in Swat today are those who would go to office every day, in bullet-proof vests and with guns in both hands, despite threats and attacks on their families by the Taliban some years ago. Change can be noted by the fact that women officers are working before office hours and female clerks are also seen to be active and serving their offices with some urgency too.
Sehat ka Insaf (the drive for polio eradication) and the Tameer-e-School Programme as well as other public-private-volunteer campaigns and programmes are catching the imagination of the people and drawing them into the process of citizenship. The right to information is taken seriously in the corridors of government in KP.
For me, simply, the credit for progress and change always goes to the people of communities and some actors who trigger change. However, governance is about enabling this change or, at the very least, not getting in the way. To the extent that corrupt officials siphon off material assistance that can enable that change, it is also worth observing that the PTI is struggling with removing and replacing those it deems to be involved in such malpractice. More important is that this is part of a broader policy of routine monitoring and not just some witch-hunt that is being implemented in the field too.
That’s the good news. Of course this is not enough. All this will be negligible and erased unless the larger issue of security is resolved. Polio cases keep popping up from Fata; girls schools have not been rebuilt; economic empowerment has not shown a pulse; beautification is a silly extravagance when Peshawar is in critical need of clinical cleaning up and, radically upgrading and equipping old hospitals is maybe more important than building new ones.
Even more critical, on the issue of security, Khan seems not to have grasped the people’s call for regaining a pre-Taliban status. It is completely inaccurate to suggest that there is consensus in KP against drones too. Instead, Khan’s confused attempt at reconciliation through appeasement of the militants may be the biggest error of judgement and against the collective wisdom of his own state officials.
Khan’s obsessive concern for ‘national security’ against foreign powers needs to be replaced by honouring a commitment to the immediate and internal security needs of his province instead. They are not always connected.
More importantly, there is underlying tension between the Punjab-led centre and Khan’s government. This is harmful. If polio vaccines are not being delivered on time or salaries for Lady Health Workers not being released for their critical work then this petty politics will only harm the people.
On the other hand, the shrieking hawks and silent doves in the PTI are equally to blame for Khan’s paranoid rant on electoral results 2013 and magnetic attraction to Islamist parties. The atrophied Islamists’ only purpose seems to be to disrupt and derail civilian democracy and they only serve as opportunist puppets.
It seems Khan is eager to even dissolve and sacrifice the KP government at the first chance while looking for opportunities that may dislodge the PML-N from the centre.
In contrast to the energy in KP, Balochistan may as well be wiped off from the imaginary of Pakistan. No forum, no aman ki asha, no NGO, no bleeding heart liberals or pious Islamists are politically committed to their cause. Punjab is a capitalist garrison with a sort-of human face but the fact is that it is committed and delivering on that front, as most conservative governments are able to.
Khan’s miscalculation is that he keeps looking in the rear-view window on his travel from Islamabad to Peshawar. Such myopia is blinding him from recognising that several constituencies in Sindh in 2013 showed that they too were inspired by his promise of change. Who can blame them? Observing the pathetic health, educational and economic situation of the despairing, bright and deserving peoples of Sindh outside of Karachi makes one believe that the worst punishment on the people of Sindh is their unimaginative and selfish leadership.
The lesson over this past year seems to be that we need to quit our hyper-nationalism and the over-drive to prove some abstract thing called ‘patriotism’. Instead, we would be better off proving our credentials as provincial compatriots. It is more patriotic to serve the people than lead them or a nation.
The writer is a sociologist based in Karachi. Email: afiyazia@yahoo.com
Now, court can only act upon applications filed under its jurisdiction
Fact is that let alone Pakistan, Trump hasn’t really spoken much for any South Asian country, not even India
By embracing quantum mechanics, humanity has unlocked technologies once thought unimaginable
Regular reporting could ensure accountability and adaptive management
Report assesses readiness of over 190 countries to meet demands of the international job market
In Pakistan, prospect of introducing Starlink has been topic of discussion, particularly due to frequent internet...