failed to inform the commentators why their critical comments were rejected or ignored.
The experts and civil society members said SEPA’s approval glossed over serious threats to public interests and the environment.
Moreover, they said, the SEPA also callously overlooked the fact that the nuclear reactor’s spent fuel storage pool could also face an accident and such an event there was nothing to stop a very high level of lethal radioactivity to be dispersed in the direction of some of the densely populated areas of the city.
They complained SEPA’s blanket approval had failed to challenge the Pakistan Atomic Energy Commission (PAEC) into including, as required by its own laws, alternative sources of electricity through wind and solar power which were the most-rapidly growing sources of electric power across the world. Even in China, they said, annual growth in nuclear power plants was only five to ten percent of the wind power plants.
Besides risks to life, the experts said, the project completely ignored the social and economic consequences of a major nuclear accident in Karachi and evacuation strategy for the people. The project’s proponents have not considered the effect of a serious reactor accident on industries and businesses.
However, they said, what was most alarming was the unreasonable refusal on the part of the PAEC to accept that a breach in the reactor area would release lethal radioactivity in the environment. They said the sea breeze blows towards the city most of the year, further augmenting the risk while the PAEC, SEPA and other relevant authorities keep refusing to accept international recommendations of building nuclear power reactors at least 30 kilometres away from population centres.
Moreover, they said, the reactor would also release a large amount of heat into the Arabian Sea for the next 60 years, harming marine life and thus the livelihood of fishermen.
Besides, the reactor was a new design which had never been tested. Hualong-1 design is a hybrid French technology and the first reactor of this kind being constructed in China with at least 15 percent of its components imported from France. The experts said China will not be allowed to use those components in the reactors being built in Karachi and instead the parts will be Chinese, making the city the first testing ground for the equipment.
They demanded that the construction of nuclear reactors should be stopped because the Environmental Impact Assessment process was deeply flawed.
This picture taken on January 30, 2023, shows commuters passing through the Empress Market in Pakistan's port city of...
Managing Director of Pak-Arab Refinery Company Irteza Ali Qureshi can be seen in this image. — PARL WebsiteLAHORE:...
Rescue 1122 ambulance seen in this image. —APP/FileIt was an ordinary day in Karachi in June last year when former...
Karachi Water and Sewerage Corporation Dhabeji pumping station's employees seen in this image. —...
The Sindh minister for home, Zia-ul-Hassan Lanjar speaks to media persons, this still released on March 18, 2024. —...
Mayor Karachi Barrister Murtaza Wahab .— Facebook@pireet/File Mayor Karachi Barrister Murtaza Wahab on Monday...