can’t really defeat our enemies.”
Ray Mabus, US Secretary of the Navy, spoke of the shootings with less clarity about the nature of the enemy: “While we expect our sailors and Marines to go into harm’s way, and they do so without hesitation, an attack at home, in our community, is insidious and unfathomable.”
Yet a few days later at least 10 Afghan soldiers – American allies – died ‘at home, in their community’ when the checkpoint they were manning in eastern Afghanistan was taken out in a US helicopter strike, which the Afghan regional commander described as “a very big mistake”. He pointed out to the Washington Post that the strikers should have known they weren’t attacking the enemy because it happened in daylight and “the Afghanistan flag was waving on our post, when we came under attack”.
Well, you know, collateral damage and all. These things happen. But somehow the deaths of these soldiers didn’t cause the same stir the Chattanooga killings did, though the victims’ lives were equally precious and were cut short in an attack that probably seemed, to them, equally unfathomable.
But, whereas the Chattanooga shootings were a ‘horrific attack’, the friendly fire killings were an ‘incident’ – just like all the other bomb and missile killings, accidental, intentional or whatever, of civilians in Afghanistan, Iraq and elsewhere over the last decade and a half. The Wall Street Journal added that the incident “threatens to strain relations” between the US and its allies in the war that has no prospect of ending, but added that “the airstrike is under investigation”, which is the epitaph of choice for news stories about to be buried for eternity.
All of which leads me back to the Norman Mailer quote, that we have no real security, just a massive power to retaliate. This is the nature of armed self-defence.
This article has been excerpted from: ‘Armed insecurity’.
Courtesy: Counterpunch.org
According to Pakistan Institute for Conflict and Security Studies , 79 terrorist attacks were recorded in February alone
Since becoming nuclear power in 1998, Pakistan has adhered to a doctrine of credible minimum deterrence
Tail-end farmers in Sindh face problems linked to growing water scarcity notably in Indus Delta and consequent erosion...
On March 16, BLA claimed responsibility for Noshki attack on security forces, killing five officers and injuring dozens
As recently adopted Pact for Future reminds us, human rights are, in fact, a source of solutions
In Punjab, over 7,000 women have filed inheritance cases since 2021, with more than 3,000 still unresolved