you are Tony Abbott, you seize upon every opportunity to talk about national security. You talk about terrorism, border security, the threat posed by Islamic fighters - and you talk about it incessantly.
You could dismiss this as political gamesmanship but in the increasingly high stakes political arena that is edging towards the possibility of an early election, is there a risk that the government is over-stating the threat posed? Just how great is the risk to Australia from ISIL and foreign fighters?
Like many western nations, a whole industry has emerged to discuss and dissect the motivations of foreign fighters but the actual figures remain opaque. While it is understandable that counting the numbers of men and women who have left Australia to fight with ISIL is an imprecise science, the available figures vary widely.
The Australian government security services estimate that around 150 to 250 fighters have left to fight for Isil. However, the most rigorous independent analysis puts the figure much lower, at just 54 Australian fighters currently in Iraq and Syria.
The April 2015 Lowy Institute poll uses open source data and, as such, is not privy to all information collected by Australia’s security services. However, the disparity in the figures is alarming. Given the frenzied media coverage given to any proven or suspected foreign fighter, it is unclear how the government’s figures could be five times higher than the figures taken from open source data.
Australia’s Foreign Minister Julie Bishop has used the government figures to issue an alarming warning. Australia, she says, is the highest contributor per capita of foreign fighters to the Middle East.
It is a startling statistic, but how accurate is it? If you are politicking largely on the promise of keeping Australia safe, does it not suit your political objectives if Australians feel unsafe?
Excerpted from: ‘Fear, loathing and Australian politics’.
Courtesy: Aljazeera.com
According to Chanakya, secret of strong nation lies in ability to protect its citizens
Rapid economic progress was made possible under Modi's leadership if not ‘Modi's guarantee’
Pakistan was considered water-abundant country, with per capita water availability being 5650 cubic meters in 1951
Shrine of Mian Mir.—TheNews/FileMy history professor once referred to a theory that says the developmental telos of...
If Pakistan does not take prompt and decisive action, it could find itself at forefront of world's first water conflict
Please note that dam survey team from World Bank had proposed building of this dam in 1955