close
Thursday November 21, 2024

Ill-timed critique

Fresh off a historic Test series victory, Shan was asked, “How did you manage six losses in a row?”

By Abdul Mohi Shah
October 28, 2024
Former PCB chairman Ramiz Raja (left) and Pakistan red ball skipper Shan Masood.—  X@TheRealPCB/file
Former PCB chairman Ramiz Raja (left) and Pakistan red ball skipper Shan Masood.—  X@TheRealPCB/file

ISLAMABAD: Pakistan cricket is no stranger to controversy, often swirling with heated debates. Sometimes these stir within the team itself, while at other times, renowned former players chime in, casting shadows even on the brightest moments.

A prime example emerged when Ramiz Raja made a surprising comment during his interview with the jubilant series-winning captain Shan Masood. Fresh off a historic Test series victory, Shan was asked, “How did you manage six losses in a row?” – an out-of-context query that seemed to downplay Pakistan’s remarkable comeback.

The timing was far from ideal. Pakistan had just overturned their losing streak to win the series against England, an extraordinary feat achieved in less than two and a half days. This moment called for celebration, recognition and respect for a team that had defied the odds. Instead, the former Pakistan Cricket Board chairman’s question came off as a dampener, overshadowing the team’s outstanding achievement.

As a former captain, one would expect Ramiz to empathize with the euphoria of a hard-fought victory, especially since he himself endured similar struggles in leadership. He could have highlighted the pivotal performances of players like Sajid Khan, Noman Ali and Saud Shakeel – unsung heroes whose grit powered Pakistan’s stunning success. But rather than lifting the jubilant team, his remarks appeared dismissive, striking a discordant note with fans eager to celebrate.

Despite Ramiz’s misplaced critique, Shan handled the situation gracefully. Yet, for many watching, the exchange left an unwelcome aftertaste, perceived as a move to undermine the collective dedication that led Pakistan to victory.

The whole nation was in a jubilant celebration, as fans from every corner reveled in the cricket team’s remarkable success. All that was needed from the ‘expert’ commentators was simple: praise the players for their achievement and add to the joy of cricket-crazed fans.

Yet, Ramiz’s comments cast a shadow over the festivities. Instead of celebrating the collective dedication and hard work behind this victory, his words seemed to diminish it, leaving a sour note in an otherwise triumphant moment.