SIESTA KEY, Florida: Chris Fiore was supposed to be accepting delivery of new household appliances and furniture, replacing items that were swamped by Hurricane Helene just a few weeks ago.
Instead, the resident of Siesta Key, the Florida barrier island town where Hurricane Milton made landfall this week, was using a broom to push muck and seawater out of her ground-floor condo, a dream home she purchased just four years ago.
“There is no chance I’m pulling up stakes,” Fiore said on Friday, pointing out the waterline where ocean water earlier this week was two feet (60 cm) up a wall. “I’m doubling down, thinking about hurricane windows and doors, figuring out how to stop this water from coming in.”
This sentiment was echoed by several residents of Siesta Key who spoke with Reuters on Friday. Residents were outnumbered by clean-up workers and people handing out cards advertising roofing and other construction services following two major hurricanes in two weeks.
All were feeling down but none seemed defeated, despite the threats of more and stronger hurricanes in the future.
“Paradise is still paradise, despite this mess,” said Pat Hurst, who along with her husband Bill has lived on Siesta Key since 2011 and has been visiting for over two decades.
“That said, cleaning up from one hurricane while trying to prepare for another was really stressful.”
While those living outside hurricane-prone zones may wonder why their residents choose to stay, it is easy to see Siesta Key’s appeal, even after a hurricane. The place is a Jimmy Buffett song come to life. The mix of low-slung homes and three-story condos are painted in pleasant pastels, and downtown is lined with appealing restaurants and bars.
After Milton, fine white beach sand covered roads several blocks inland. Homes were turned inside out, with every imaginable household possession ruined by Helene heaped along roads. Coconuts were blown from trees and thrown asunder.
Boats normally docked in canals were tossed on land. Dumpsters already full from the Helene cleanup were being topped by Milton’s debris.
Milton, the fifth-most-intense Atlantic hurricane on record, intensified quickly from a Category 1 storm to the maximum Category 5 at sea in less than 24 hours, the latest example of a trend of storms growing more powerful, more quickly, because of climate change.
Milton made landfall as a Category 3. At least 17 deaths were attributed to Milton, according to media outlets.
Asked by reporters about possible discussion of not letting people rebuild, Florida Governor Ron DeSantis said on Friday “the reality is people work their whole lives to be able to live in environments that are really, really nice, and they have a right to make those decisions with their property as they see fit.”
“It is not the role of government to forbid them or to force them to dispose or utilize their property in a way that they do not think is best for them,” DeSantis said.
Florida has led the nation in population growth since 2021 despite a low-lying topography that leaves it vulnerable to hurricanes and rising sea levels.
Florida ZIP codes account for 78 of the 80 riskiest areas in the country, according to Weather Source, an environmental risk consultancy. Residents paid an average of $4,060 for property insurance in 2023, nearly $1,000 higher than any other state.
Sherry Tom, 49, convinced her husband and three daughters to leave Pittsburgh’s cold winters and move to Siesta Key in 2021.
“This place is my whole heart,” she said. “But I will admit - I’m worried about living in fear that this will happen again. But if we can, we’re staying.”
Tom said she thinks that they will have to knock down what remains of their home and build from scratch. She was resolute about staying.
Marko Radosavljevic, 54, owns one of the original homes built by Siesta Key’s first developer, Frank Archibald. Coral green, it was built with pecky cypress wood, and is known for its water resistance. Water and wind have nonetheless done damage in the past two weeks.
As he worked to clean out debris from the house he’s owned since 2017, Radosavljevic said he was not even considering leaving behind a place “with a special island vibe.”
“I refuse to be pushed out,” Radosavljevic said, referring to both storms and drives to put up hotels in place of older homes like his.
