close
Instep Today

What caught our eye this week

By Maheen Sabeeh
Sun, 09, 24

From seasoned actors criticizing colleagues to a designer being called out for plagiarism and a stylist comparing younger actors to their older counterparts, here’s what made news this week.

What caught our eye this week

Pakistan’s entertainment industry is frequently plagued by controversies. Before the rise of social media, it was easier to avoid scrutiny for misconduct. However, the advent of digital platforms, smartphones, and constant news coverage has made it increasingly difficult to conceal such transgressions. As the industry faces heightened scrutiny, it is imperative for insiders to prioritize ethical conduct, transparency, and mutual support to foster a healthier and more positive environment. Otherwise, such stories automatically make news.

Firdous Jamal is at it again

Firdous Jamal, a veteran actor in Pakistan’s entertainment industry, has a history of making controversial statements about industry figures. He once again sparked controversy with his comments about prominent industry figures.

In a recent appearance on a talk show, Jamal made allegations against Humayun Saeed, suggesting that the actor’s star power allows him to secure roles that might otherwise go to more deserving actors. When the host pointed out Saeed’s popularity and high earnings, Jamal dismissed his achievements, comparing him to a smuggler and using derogatory terms as comparison. These terms are offensive and inappropriate and should not be used for anyone, let alone on television for an accomplished actor. While Jamal acknowledged that Saeed has appeared in a few decent serials, his overall tone was critical. This isn’t the first time Jamal has expressed his opinions on industry figures. In 2019, he sparked significant controversy with his comments about Mahira Khan, criticizing her age and suggesting that she was too old to play romantic lead roles. His remarks fueled conversations about the challenges women face in the entertainment industry, particularly regarding ageism and gender bias.

What caught our eye this week

However, in a recent talk show, when questioned about Mahira Khan’s appearance in The Legend of Maula Jatt, and whether he would reconsider his past comments, Firdous Jamal refused to do so. Instead, he praised the beauty of classic actresses like Elizabeth Taylor, Nargis, and Madhubala, claiming that his own opinion is subjective. While personal opinions are acceptable, it’s inappropriate to publicly criticize an actress’s appearance and suggest that she is too “old” to play leading roles. When you say controversial things for no rhyme or reason, it can spark some form of exchange. In response to Firdous Jamal’s controversial statements, Humayun Saeed shared a post made by Yasir Hussain. Yasir expressed his admiration for Humayun Saeed, calling him the biggest film star in Pakistan.

However, Yasir also noted that while Firdous Jamal is a brilliant actor, it’s inappropriate at his age to invite him on shows and ask such questions. He suggested getting Jamal’s views on Mahira Khan and Humayun Saeed in writing on stamp paper and then giving him a break. Humayun Saeed reshared Yasir’s post, adding: “Yes, to all the hosts.”

Ageism is a pervasive issue in the enter-tainment industry, both domestically and internationally. It’s important to remember that creating controversies or seeking attention does not justify disparaging the work of other actors. It is concerning that such misogynistic and ageist comments continue to be made on television shows by so-called “experts.” While balanced criticism is valuable, comments that focus solely on looks, age, and gender demonstrate how some veteran actors lack an understanding of current concepts of diversity and inclusivity. Television channels should be more mindful of the guests they invite onto their programs, ensuring that they contribute genuine and unbiased perspectives.

Maria B’s controversial design accusations

What caught our eye this week


Always—at least according to my personal opinion—on the wrong side of issues, designer Maria B is facing allegations of plagiarism. A social media user recently pointed out that a dress from Maria B’s collection closely resembled a design by Turkish artist, Hac Balina Atölye. The similarities between the two designs were striking, particularly in terms of their design elements, patterns, and overall aesthetic. Many observers noted that Maria B’s work appeared to be a direct copy.

This plagiarism allegation quickly gained momentum on social media, with users pointing out the similarities and accusing Maria B of copying. This controversy further damaged Maria B’s public reputation, which had already been marred by other controversies.

Maria B did apologize for the similarities between her design and Hac Balina Atölye‘s, acknowledging that her work had been influenced by the Turkish design. She clarified that the similarities were unintentional and not meant to undermine the Turkish artist’s work. Since the incident, the artist has given Maria B permission to use her design in her Palestine collection.

However, this incident serves as a reminder that in the age of social media, it is nearly impossible to use the word “inspiration” if you’re going to copy another person’s work and pass it off as your own, even if you are working in two different countries. And if anyone should learn a lesson from this, it is Maria B.

Waqar Hussain highlights challenges faced by makeup artists in the industry

Waqar Hussain, a prominent figure in the Pakistani entertainment and fashion industry, is a respected makeup artist and actor. Known for his work in dramas, films, advertisements, and theater, he recently discussed the changing landscape of the industry on Fahad’s Den, a digital talk show.

Hussain noted a growing sense of repetitiveness and monotony, attributing it to the decline of experienced makeup artists. He observed that older stars were generally more adaptable and open to collaboration, while many current celebrities prefer to work with their own teams, limiting opportunities for other artists.

This shift, he believes, hinders the advancement of new talent. He reflected on the uniformity of makeup and modeling aesthetics in the contemporary industry, contrasting it with the versatility of past models like Iraj. He recalled how Iraj could effortlessly elevate even the simplest attire, arresting the audience with her unique style.

He observed that modern models often lack such individuality, and the widespread use of Photoshop and AI software further complicates the issue, making it challenging to distinguish authentic work. He questioned the value of makeup artists in an industry where designers or models may prioritize digital alterations over artistic expression.

Hussain further highlighted the trend of established makeup artists shifting their focus to salon work, avoiding on-set assignments due to the prevailing negativity in those environments. This shift, he believes, has contributed to the departure of many seasoned artists from the industry.

In conclusion, Waqar Hussain’s insights shed light on the evolving challenges faced by makeup artists in Pakistan’s entertainment and fashion industry.

He emphasizes the detrimental impact of current trends, such as the preference for digital enhancements over traditional artistry and the decline in collaboration opportunities for new talent.

His observations serve as a call for the industry to maintain the creative integrity that once set it apart, encouraging a more inclusive and supportive environment for both emerging and seasoned makeup artists.

12 years later: Fawad Khan and Mahira Khan

What caught our eye this week

Fawad Khan and Mahira Khan first starred as co-stars in Sarmad Khoosat’s Humsafar nearly 12 years ago. The series was a huge success, but an even bigger success was the pairing of Fawad Khan and Mahira Khan. Since then, they have appeared on talk shows together, participated in fashion shoots, and starred in Hindi films individually. Mahira Khan starred opposite Shah Rukh Khan in Raees while Fawad Khan appeared in films such as Khoobsurat, Kapoor & Sons, and Ae Dil Hai Mushkil in a small but significant role. He also made a cameo in a Hollywood television series, Ms. Marvel. Both are among Pakistan’s most popular actors. When they starred in the blockbuster hit, The Legend of Maula Jatt, it was made clear by both the actors that the film was not exactly a love story focused on them, though the two characters did share some scenes. 

 
What caught our eye this week

Fans have been waiting since Humsafar for a film or series in which the two appear as co-stars, and that dream is finally being fulfilled with Neelofar, an upcoming film featuring Mahira Khan, Fawad Khan and Madiha Imam. Neelofar, a Geo Film, is co-produced by Fawad Khan, and for this film, Mahira Khan had already committed to dates, which meant she couldn’t do Kamli and play the role of the protagonist, which was eventually played by Saba Qamar. But we think it was serendipity for two reasons: one, now that we’ve seen Kamli, we don’t think anyone could’ve done a better job; and two, this major reunion of Fawad and Mahira on the big screen had to happen.

What caught our eye this week

The timing is perfect because both have played several roles since Humsafar and fans have been eagerly waiting for an official reunion. So, Neelofar will make many, many fans very happy. How the film performs depends on the story, execution, screenplay and many other factors that contribue to the making of a film. For now, though, rejoice that both of these actors have decided to star in a film that will focus on them and not a major ensemble.